Link back to Katt & Company home page Katt & Company Logo Link to articles written by Peter Katt Link to Alerts, Tips and Information Learn more about Katt & Company Peter Katt Biography
no image no image no image no image
Link to what's new from Katt & Company Fee-only Life Insurance Advisors Recent Case Profiles no image no image
 
Vol 9 No 7
August 2007


 

Katt & Company is a national fee-only life insurance advising firm. The June 2002 Forbes magazine, and a July 16, 2003 Wall Street Journal article, name Peter Katt as one of only four nationally recognized advisors. The Forbes article states that, "…advisers are well worth the money… These savants are working for no one but you…" For references please contact us.


Creative Analysis of Term Insurance

Although term life insurance is far less complex than permanent insurance, it isn't exactly checkers either. Implementing term insurance often needs more than just sorting through companies to find the least expensive and rushing out with the application. This isn't an-all-you-need-to-know-about-term piece, rather it focuses on several creative analysis and approaches to the term insurance topic that may add value for your clients.

 

Why Use Term

There are two reasons to use term insurance. One is because the need is temporary. Such temporary needs can be: family protection; funding a buy-sell agreement when business partners intend to sell or liquidate around retirement age; or for estate tax liquidity if difficult to sell assets are expected to be liquidated within a reasonable period. For life insurance needs that will extend past life expectancy or for life, permanent life insurance is needed. We might think of term insurance as if-I-die coverage and permanent as for when-I-die.

The other reason to use term insurance is when the need is permanent but there is inadequate cash flow to spend on permanent insurance at the present time. Term should be used in these situations and then switching to permanent insurance later. Do not fall prey to agents peddling premium financing of permanent insurance premiums in this cash poor situation. I have observed very bad results because of interest rate changes when this has been done and even when interest rates aren't adverse the long-term results aren't as good as starting with term and using permanent when cash flow has improved.

Low-Load UL as Surrogate Term

Estate tax liquidity needs can be filled using joint life because the estate tax is due at the second spouse's death. Not all liquidity needs are permanent. The ideal solution for joint life insurance needed for a limited period is low-load survivorship universal life (SUL) that insures both lives. A good source for low-load SUL is www.ameritasdirect.com. In my experience this alternative has substantially less cost than the few joint term policies available or insuring the least expensive spouse with conventional one-life term. A California client (72 and 70) needed additional liquidity for ten years. A true joint life 10-year term policy for the $2,000,000 needed had an annual premium of $6,285. Term on the wife only had premiums of $10,000 a year for 10-year term. An Ameritas low-load joint life SUL funded for 10 years had target premiums of $4,885. Not only does the low-load SUL have less cost but it has a surrender value if the insurance isn't needed for the full 10 years. For example, if the policy is terminated in the seventh year the cash value is around $18,000. The SUL is permanent insurance, so it can be continued as long as it is being properly funded. While the true term policies have guaranteed premiums and the SUL's are not, the short period involved means there will be little fluctuation in the SUL $4,885 target premiums and if interest rates go up the premium could even decline a bit.

When single-life term and low-load UL underwriting is the same (e.g., preferred), term will have a substantial pricing advantage. But I have had situations where term underwriting is less favorable than UL (e.g., term is standard and UL is preferred). When this occurs and the premiums are similar for the period of time being considered, UL is the better choice because of the surrender cash value and also UL is permanent insurance so no conversion is needed.

Conversion of Term to Permanent Insurance

The right to convert from term insurance to permanent without proof of insurability is very important, but judgment needs to be used in knowing if and when to convert. Most term policies have conversion rights that are the same as the term length, say, 20-years (usually with a maximum age of 75). (But don't assume that the conversion right is for the level premium period. It may not. For example, some term policies limit the conversion period to five years even though they are 20-year level term policies).

Let's examine three situations. Mike has a 20-year $1,000,000 term policy taken out at age 40 with preferred rating. He arrives at age 60 in the same health, albeit the passage of 20 years, and wants to continue the coverage permanently. In the months leading up to the end of his low-cost premium rate Mike should examine the entire life insurance market place, including the conversion, to determine the best policy. Most likely the best policy will not be the conversion policy. Because he remains a preferred insurance risk he is not limited by the conversion.

Another situation could be that Mike has a heart attack at 51. Agents often rush in to handle an immediate conversion. This is very likely a mistake. To determine if conversion should occur early you need to know the cost to convert now and at the end of the conversion period. Subtract the term premium from the permanent policy premium if converted immediately. Let's say this difference is $10,855. Mike can save $10,855 for the next nine years by waiting. At 4.5% this has a value in nine years of $122,534. You then need to find out what the cost of permanent insurance is in nine years, the deadline to convert, and subtract the cost of doing so now. Let's say the annual premium to convert in nine year is $7,658 more. With this information you can determine how long it takes for the $122,534 side-fund to be used up from the $7,658 additional cost starting in nine years. The answer is 27 years, using a 4.5% rate. That is, waiting to convert the term insurance until age 60 will be the financially astute move if Mike dies before 87. Due to the heart attack his life expectancy at 60 is 21 years. This means he has about a 25% probability of making it to 87. Therefore, there is a 75% probability that waiting nine years to convert is the right move. (I used no lapse UL as the conversion policies. The cost of UL in nine years will change. It could be higher or lower and this will affect the relative advantage of waiting to convert).

The third situation is that Mike finds out he has terminal cancer at age 53, with a maximum three years to survive. The obvious decision is to keep the much lower cost term insurance that has another seven years until the conversion deadline occurs. This hasn't been obvious to the insurance agents that have rushed in trying to convert in this circumstance in several cases I have been involved with.

Family Protection Insurance

For clients in the raising families and accumulating wealth economic stage of their lives, term insurance is the major life insurance type to use, probably mixed in with some discounted whole life that is used for the dual purposes of family protection and tax-deferred cash value accumulation. Also term insuring the non primary-income earner is recommended to help manage a single-parent household. Having this term insurance owned by and payable to irrevocable trusts should be considered. So many times I have seen such clients underinsured because they have been sold only permanent insurance. This is a mistake. If-I-die insurance is so cost effective for insuring the large amounts that are needed to provide financial security to the family your client leaves behind, that it is malpractice not to get the amounts right.

I find a good source for term pricing information to be found at www.term4sale.com.


 

 


Katt & Company • 890 Treasure Island Drive • Mattawan, MI 49071
Phone: 269.372.3497 • Fax: 269.372.4681
Email: PKatt@PeterKatt.com